Tempt Your Tastebuds

Horatio's Homemade Ice Cream is a locally, family-owned and operated, small batch ice cream shop in downtown Custer,  South Dakota, the oldest town in the Black Hills.  We are located  in the 1881 First National Bank of Dakota Territory Building, listed on the National Register of Historic Places.    We make our ice cream in-house and aim to provide a rotation of ice cream, sherbet, sorbet and non-dairy options which are rich, creamy and flavorful to locals and tourists alike.  Many of our most popular flavors are unique to our location!  In fact, we often offer seasonal flavors which utilize local ingredients-flavors like Bob's Bees Honey Cashew and our seasonal rhubarb ice cream!  Enjoy them while they last! In addition to our homemade ice cream, we also offer homemade and freshly baked waffle cones! Our menu also features sundaes, floats and  ice cream sandwiches.  Fresh brewed coffee and ice tea are also available.  Flavors are ever-changing, keeping it fresh! We are open seasonally, mid-March through October, and have pop-up dates throughout the winter.  We think our ice cream is as good as gold!